Discussion utilisateur:Ed g2s
Please leave messages here: en:user talk:ed g2s
Votre modification a été annulée
Bonjour et merci pour vos apports.
Je suis membre de la patrouille, je fais partie des bénévoles qui regardent les modifications récentes de Wikipédia. J'ai annulé vos modifications car vous avez ajouté un ou plusieurs liens externes inappropriés. Or, ces liens sont réservés à des sites de référence reconnus : sites officiels, universités, gouvernements, etc.
Si votre lien apporte un complément d'information encyclopédique et fiable à un point de l'article, il est recommandé de le citer comme source à l'endroit de l'information concernée (aide). Dans le cas contraire, ne l'ajoutez pas à l'article.
Pour davantage de précisions, vous pouvez lire la page consacrée aux liens externes et poser vos questions sur le forum des nouveaux contributeurs. Vous pouvez aussi me contacter.
N'hésitez pas également à consulter nos parcours d'initiation à Wikipédia et le sommaire de l'aide.
Je vous souhaite de bonnes futures contributions sur Wikipédia !Stéphane (d) 29 janvier 2009 à 13:30 (CET)
Spam[modifier le code]
Apologies for writing in English. What is wrong with adding external links to free (libre) sheet music (partitions)? I am an administrator on the English Wikipedia, and links like these are welcome there. Ed g2s (d) 29 janvier 2009 à 13:35 (CET)
- Hi, there's nothing wrong with adding external links but on the French Wikipedia, we consider spammers people who just add an external link to an article but do not contribute to the article at all. You've had less than 10 contributions on the French Wikipedia and they all consisted in adding a link to a newly created (personnal?) website. Our policy concerning external links is here: Wikipédia:Liens externes. Stéphane (d) 29 janvier 2009 à 13:59 (CET)
- And I would say that for a free sheet music, the solution would be to upload the partition on commons:Category:Sheet music of Ludwig van Beethoven (there's nothing more than File:Fur-elise-preview.png apparently) instead of relying on an external website. Stéphane (d) 29 janvier 2009 à 14:06 (CET)
- Well yes, but I don't see why you should evaluate my contributions to Wikimedia projects within the scope of one language wiki. I have made thousands of contributions across many sub-projects, 99% of which are not external links, but there seems to be a lack of links to usable sheet music. The site is not a personal project. Also, the Commons has very limited PDF support. Personally I think users benefit from such sources. If you agree then feel free to restore the links. Ed g2s (d) 29 janvier 2009 à 14:17 (CET)
- I'm not judging your work, I'm just telling you how we deal with external links here and newly registered editors adding external links to articles.
- There are hundreds of websites that offer sheet music of La Lettre à Élise (for example) for free so why should we promote this one?
- Since they're in the public domain and since Commons already has some in commons:Category:Sheet music of Ludwig van Beethoven, they should be uploaded there (pdf, png, gif, I'm not sure what the best format would be). Stéphane (d) 29 janvier 2009 à 14:49 (CET)
- Well yes, but I don't see why you should evaluate my contributions to Wikimedia projects within the scope of one language wiki. I have made thousands of contributions across many sub-projects, 99% of which are not external links, but there seems to be a lack of links to usable sheet music. The site is not a personal project. Also, the Commons has very limited PDF support. Personally I think users benefit from such sources. If you agree then feel free to restore the links. Ed g2s (d) 29 janvier 2009 à 14:17 (CET)
- And I would say that for a free sheet music, the solution would be to upload the partition on commons:Category:Sheet music of Ludwig van Beethoven (there's nothing more than File:Fur-elise-preview.png apparently) instead of relying on an external website. Stéphane (d) 29 janvier 2009 à 14:06 (CET)
